Monday, January 31, 2011

The Strong-Willed Child

The Strong-Willed Child: Birth Through AdolescenceThe Strong-Willed Child: Birth Through Adolescence by James C. Dobson

My rating: 3 of 5 stars






View all my reviews

It's becoming clear that little E has a very independent spirit. Which is good, really, it'll make her a critical thinker and strong individual. We think already that her physical looks are from her Daddy, but her personality, for better or worse, is definitely more like her Mama's.

But, her strong spirit is going to take some serious molding to really make it shine. Mama and Daddy know best, regardless of what the little one thinks. So, I read this book in order to get a sense of Dr. Dobson's perspective on the matter. I have to say, I went in with a really bad attitude towards Dobson (the reasons for which is a long, long story worthy only of being told in person). In The Strong-Willed Child, Dobson has the same paternalistic, agenda-pushing tone that I remember from previous encounters.

BUT. I did get several good ideas out of the book, including the necessity for consistency, regardless of the kind of punishment, and the importance of avoiding empty threats. There were several chapters on later childhood which I may have to revisit at a later date, but for now, I think I have some solid concepts to work towards.

And, finally, one can't discuss The Strong-Willed Child without mentioning spanking, which Dr. Dobson wholeheartedly endorses (with certain limits). I'm very on the fence regarding the use of spanking (my fence-sitting is the subject for another in-person discussion), and Dobson's said endorsement changes none of my hesitance.

2 comments:

Peter and Lorraine said...

Like any book you read - ask for Godly discernment as you travel through the pages. Round out your reading with other books on a similar subject. There must be a wealth of information waiting to be explored!

Marco, Kristin, and Ellie de Andrade said...

Can't wait for coffee together!